Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs of 2020

Spread the love

Stubborn dogs can be a real pain to train, but with the right tools it’s not impossible. One of the best training tools is the training collar, but of course, there are tons of options you can consider. To make things easier for you, we will take a look at the 5 best training collars for stubborn dogs.

Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs Reviews

Garmin Delta XC Bundle Dog Training Device

Garmin Delta XC Bundle - dog training device
  • LONG/SHORT CONTACTS : Includes long and short changeable/replaceable contact points ; Collar compatibility: 1.9 centimeter (0.75 inch).Control Method:Remote.Special Feature:durable.
  • STIMULATION LEVELS : Improved stimulation levels; features 18 levels of momentary and continuous stimulation, plus tone and vibration
  • RANGE : Gives 1/2 mile range capability to correct your dog’s behavior while out in the field
  • TRAINING CONFIGS : 3 correction/training configurations for different behavioral issues; Train 1, 2 or 3 dogs, settable on the handheld (with purchase of additional dog devices)
  • DURABILITY : Rugged, compact 3 button handheld controller and dog device with water rating of IPX71.Water rating: yes (IPX7)

This is a high-quality and somewhat costly dog training collar that should do the trick even for the stubbornest of dogs.


This collar is designed for trouble cases, as it comes with nearly 20 levels of stimulation. Yes, this is a shock collar, and it can be adjusted to give your dog just a very small shock or quite the zap as well. This is ideal for large dogs with thick fur that may not feel the smaller shocks.

In case you think that is a little much, this collar also allows for vibration and sound training, not just “stimulation.” Keep in mind that this item is not designed for small dogs.

We like how the Garmin Delta XC Bundle Dog Training Device is designed for durability, as all components are made with solid parts and are nearly 100% waterproof. What’s also nice is how the controller has a ½-mile range, plus a great battery life (80 hours per charge).


  • Durable
  • Multiple correction modes
  • Great for trouble cases
  • Awesome battery life
  • Good range
  • Adjustable stimulation levels


  • Quite expensive
  • Batteries degrade rather quickly over time

SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainer

SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers - 500 Yard Range E-Collar with Static, Vibrate and Tone - Waterproof, Rechargeable - Stubborn Dog Training Collar
  • HIGHER RANGES OF STIM: Designed for high drive/stubborn dogs that do not respond to lower levels of static stimulation
  • 500 YARD RANGE: e-collar that can support training up to 3 dogs with the same remote with purchase of additional collars (SDR-AXS). For dogs 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes 5" - 22".
  • NO LOOK OPERATION: Designed for ease-of-use and no look operation while offering more levels of stimulation which allows for more customized training.
  • TONE, VIBRATE, AND STIM: This electric e collar offers 21 levels of static stimulation with medium/high ranges. Option to train with vibration (buzz) and tone (beep), too.
  • WATERPROOF: Submersible to 25 feet using DryTek technology.

Here we have a slightly more expensive collar than the one we just looked at, but it is also a bit more durable and has some increased functionality.


The SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainer is designed for extreme trouble cases, as it has 21 levels of stimulation, with the highest level providing quite a zap. It’s ideal for dogs who won’t listen otherwise. What is also cool is that a single remote can control 3 separate collars.

This training collar has a range of 500 yards, plus both the collar and the controller take only 2 hours to charge, but can last for up to 70 hours on a single charge.

Moreover, the SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainer is very durable, as it is highly impact-resistant, plus it is designed to be waterproof down to 25 feet. It also features a 1-year warranty in case something goes wrong with it.

Keep in mind that this collar is quite versatile in terms of size, as it can be adjusted to fit dogs with neck sizes between 5 and 22 inches.


  • Very durable + waterproof
  • For extreme trouble cases
  • 21 levels of stimulation + sound & vibration
  • Good warranty
  • Fits many sizes of dogs
  • Good range
  • Good battery life


  • Quite expensive
  • Charging cable are not spectacular

Educator K9 Handler Remote Dog Training Collar

Educator K9 Tactical Dog Handler with Remote, 100 Levels Humane Stimulation, Pavlovian Tone, Waterproof, Odorproof Biothane Bungee Collar, Night Light, Rechargeable, 1 Mile 1 Dog, 33" Collar, Black
  • E-Collar K9-800 B33 one big dog system with 1 mile range, medium/large receiver for large dogs 20 pounds and up with neck size 12 to 23 inches
  • Includes 1 Biothane Bungee dog collar (1" wide x 33" long), 1 RX-120 large receiver (2.7" long x 1.7" wide x 1.2" high, 4 oz.) and 1 ergonomic "stopwatch" transmitter (2.75" diameter x 1.2" thick x 4.6" high) allows you to watch your dog at all times and in situations where discretion is important
  • Delivers a tapping sensation similar to vibration, but more intense, making it an effective addition to the stimulation
  • A Pavlovian tone feature provides an effective addition to the stimulation
  • User-selectable stimulation levels from 1 to 100 with additional boost stimulus selectable from 1 to 60

This is by far the most expensive dog training collar on our list so far today. It is a heavy-duty collar with some really amazing features.


One of the most impressive features is how the Educator K9 Handler Remote Dog Training Collar has a range of 1 mile. Keep in mind that this collar is designed for large dogs of 20 pounds or over.

What is also impressive is that this collar features 100 levels of electric stimulation, plus another 60 levels of so called “boost.” This feature adds a tapping feeling to the mix to help get your dog’s attention.

The controller is pretty cool, as it features an ergonomic design and looks like a stopwatch. It’s very easy to control. It is waterproof and can even float on water, something which most other training collars cannot do.


  • Superior durability
  • Great range
  • Ideal for large problem dogs
  • Many levels of stimulation + boost
  • Waterproof + floats
  • Comfortable for the dog


  • Very expensive
  • Not for small dogs

SportDOG Brand SportTrainer

SportDOG Brand SportTrainer Dog Training Collars - 500 Yard Range - Bright, Easy to Read OLED Screen - Waterproof, Rechargeable Remote Trainer with Tone, Vibration, and Static - 2 Dog Expandable
  • 500 YARD RANGE: Designed for field training and hunting with close-working dogs. Train up to 2 dogs with the same handheld remote with purchase of additional Add-A-Dog Collar (SDR-AXF). For dogs 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes 5"-22".
  • OLED SCREEN: Easy-to-read screen means you can view the selected dog, static stimulation level, and battery status with just a glance.
  • 10 LEVELS OF STIMULATION: 10 levels of both continuous and momentary static stimulation, as well as vibration (buzz) and tone (beep) options allow you to customize this system.
  • WATERPROOF: Submersible to 25 feet using DryTek technology.
  • RECHARGEABLE BATTERY: Lithium-ion batteries charge in 2 hours. Remote Transmitter battery lasts 20-40 hours per charge. Collar Receiver lasts 50-70 hours per charge. System has low battery indicators.

This is yet another high-end dog training collar, which comes with a bright orange collar so your dog will always be easy to spot.


The SportDOG Brand SportTrainer features an effective range of 500 yards, plus, with a simple 2 hour charge, both the collar and the controller can last for up to 70 hours.

What’s pretty cool is that a single controller can be used to control 2 collars at once. Moreover, the collars and the controllers both feature DryTek technology which means that they are waterproof even when submerged down to 25 feet.

Keep in mind that the SportDOG Brand SportTrainer is designed to fit dogs 8 pounds and up with neck sizes between 5 and 22 inches. This collar features multiple levels of stimulation, plus you can also use tones and vibrations as well.


  • One controller can control 2 collars
  • Waterproof to 25 feet
  • Fits most dogs
  • Stimulation + vibration + sound
  • Good range
  • Impressive battery life


  • Not overly resistant to impacts

Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar

Dog Training Collar with Remote - 3960Ft, Hunting Standard, Removable Shock, LED Light, Vibrate, Anti Bark, Beep Mode, Rechargeable Waterproof E Collar for All Dogs Over 15lbs
  • FANTASTIC NEW UPGRADE SINCE MAY= 4.7* + EXTRA LONG & REMOVE THE SHOCK PRONGS + NO STANDBY MODE ALWAYS READY + ANTI BARK & LIGHT NIGHT MODE! Is your dog misbehaving and you want a well behaved pet with minimal fuss? The Pet Resolve system is the perfect solution to train upto 3 dogs for a range of desirable behaviors. Don't let your dog get side-tracked by other animals or misbehave in public. Teach your canine companion how to act properly with arguably the top training collar on the market!
  • SUPER LONG RANGE AND MEMORY; forget other dog training collars which use cheap plastic that breaks when you drop it and are designed for small spaces and yards, our e collar dog training system is of the highest quality and has a super long 3/4 Mile range (1312 yards suitable for hunting dogs) for easy outdoor training covering the widest areas! You certainly get what you pay for with training collars and unfortunately most cheap collars won't last long!
  • VARIABLE SHOCK & VIBRATION LEVELS, ANTI BARK & LIGHT for NIGHT MODE; train up to 3 dogs at once (additional collars required) with up to 10 levels of continuous or momentary shock (hold down button to shock for 1 up to 8 seconds, ideal for emergencies!) vibrations, or beeps, for safe, efficient training, allowing you to teach your dog a range of commands. Sometimes it only takes one click of a button to completely change the behavior of your dog and the vibration button does the job for most!
  • WATERPROOF CONSTRUCTION; does your dog love to run outside or swim? Unlike cheap collars, our training system is completely waterproof (remote splash proof) and can be fully submerged without damage! Most other collars fail in the rain, we provide shock collars dogs can actually swim in all year round! It's worth noting that this collar doesn't go in to standby mode like most, meaning that it's ready to use when you actually need it!
  • ULTRA LONG LASTING BATTERY & WARRANTY for LARGE, MEDIUM AND SMALL DOGS OVER 15LBS; our training collar is powered by a super high capacity rechargeable Li-ion battery, fully charged in 2 hours (Charge above 32 fahrenheit in the house) , for long lasting training without having to constantly change batteries! You also get a warranty included no questions asked and World Class Customer Service!

This is one of the more affordable training collars on our list today, but just because it is reasonably priced does not mean that it can’t get the job done.


The Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar features 10 levels of intermittent or constant shocks, and you can also choose to use the sound and/or vibration modes as well.

The ¾-mile range of this collar is quite impressive, not to mention that the batteries can last for nearly 70 hours on a quick 2-hour charge.

Although it’s not the most expensive collar around, it is still fairly durable, plus waterproof too, so there is no need to worry about getting it wet. What’s also cool is that this single remote can control up to 3 collars at once.


  • Reasonably priced
  • Fairly durable
  • Great range
  • Great battery life
  • 1 controller for 3 collars


  • Impact resistance is a bit limited


There you have the 5 best training collars for stubborn dogs. Each one is a little different, although they all share some similarities.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: